The Biggest Lead Generation Mistakes Local Service Companies Make

What Exactly Is A Lead?

WARNING: Some digital marketing agencies classify almost every small action as a lead. Someone reads your blog post = Lead. Another person shares your social media post = Lead. Clicking on an email = Lead. Asking a question = Lead. Watching a video = Lead.

These are NOT leads.

Here is the strict definition of a lead in marketing: A prospective customer who has ENGAGED with your business and PROVIDED information to LEARN more or take the NEXT STEP.

Here are a few examples:

• Direct Inquiry Leads
• Digital Engagement Leads
• Product or Service Trial Leads
• Content Download Leads
• Phone Calls and Emails

Each of these examples of leads literally lead to a prospect taking one giant step closer to doing business with you. Leads turn into conversations. Conversations become proposals. Proposals become sales. And sales are the revenue and profits you seek.

Does Your Home Services Lead Generation System Rely on Hope and Luck? 

Too many local home services businesses either have ZERO lead generation system or a BROKEN lead generation system. Do either of those describe YOU?

If you answer “No” to most of these questions then your home services lead generation system is either broken or nonexistent:

• Do you have a consistent influx of leads in your pipeline?
• Do you get quality leads? Do most of your lead prospects do business with you?
• Is your business consistently producing solid revenue most every month?
• Do you have a proven process to reply to leads quickly and efficiently?
• Do you have a proactive follow-up system that keeps your leads engaged?

Fact is, your business may not have a sales problem. It may have a lead generation problem. Good news: this blog post aims to FIX that problem!

But, before we can fix your home services lead generation problem, we must identify the top 6 mistakes local home services businesses make when it comes to consistently generating quality leads.

Lead Generation Mistake #1: Random Acts of Marketing

Too many home services companies approach marketing as a collection of random activities, such as:

• Running some Google Ads until their ad budget gets burned
• Posting on social media when they remember
• Updating their website once every couple of years
• Sending emails to their customers once a quarter

Not only does this inconsistent marketing rarely produce leads, because they act as separate tactics, there’s zero connection. If done right, your local service company marketing should work like a network. A real home services lead generation system connects every channel into one strategy.

• Your ads should drive traffic to high-converting pages.
• Your website should build trust instantly.
• Your SEO should support long-term visibility.

Your results: you have multiple quality leads funneling from multiple marketing campaigns.

Lead Generation Mistake #2: Driving Traffic to a Broken Website

While the number of visitors you get to your site is a vanity metric, it means little to nothing unless a good chunk of those visitors become qualified leads and sales. Unfortunately, too many home services business owners are wasting their marketing dollars on a website that doesn’t convert.

Here are the common website conversion issues that Spartan Digital Solutions quite often fixes for local home services companies:

• Doesn’t clearly explain what they do
• Lacks strong calls-to-action
• Loads slowly on mobile devices
• Feels outdated or untrustworthy

Rather than focus on bringing more traffic to your broken website, work to improve your site’s conversion rate. Without spending more in advertising, you can improve your website content, add trust signals, and make it easier to connect. These simple modifications can help to improve your lead generation.

Lead Generation Mistake #3: Failure to Track Calls, Forms, and Lead Quality

Are you treating your leads like GOLD? You should be. Every lead that comes in is a prospect raising their hand to say, “I’m interested in your service.”

Yet, if you ignore that lead and fail to record and track it, your whole marketing system collapses. By failing to track your leads, you:

• Don’t know which marketing source generated the lead
• Aren’t sure which campaigns produce the best customers
• Have no clue what your actual cost per lead is
• Don’t know if leads are converting into appointments and sales

In other words, you’re flying blind. That’s no way to run a home services business.

By setting up a proper Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system, you’ll know at a glance if your home services company is moving towards its goals or not. Then, you can quickly adjust your local service company marketing, improve campaigns, and respond to the market. That’s how you grow… fast!

Lead Generation Mistake #4: Measuring Activity Instead of Real Results

Back in the ‘50s when advertising agencies were booming, results were measured by ringing phones, orders, and sales. Today, we have literally dozens of ways to measure the success of marketing and specific campaigns.

For websites, you have unique visits, time on page, clicks, form fills, traffic, and more. For social media, you can measure impressions, follows, Likes, shares, comments, and more. For emails, you typically measure open rates, click through rates, and engagement.

The sad truth is that none of these watered down metrics pay the bills. While each metric can be a good indication of future growth, here are the real metrics that move the needle. These are the ones you need to pay attention to:

• Qualified leads (phone calls, form fills, email inquiries, conversations, etc.)
• Booked meetings, consultations, and estimates
• Booked jobs
• Revenue generated
• Customer lifetime value

Never confuse “marketing activity” with real results. A successful home services lead generation system should deliver real results that lead to profitable growth.

Lead Generation Mistake #5: Ignoring Google Business Profile and Local Visibility

Where do you go when you want to check out who has the best Chinese food in town? Or find an oil change service that’s nearby? Or need a haircut from a local barber or salon?

In most cases, you run straight to Google and type in a search: “Best Chinese restaurant near me.” And the results that appear are local recommendations from Google under their Google Business Profile service.

Well, your prospects and customers search for you and your competitors in the exact same way. Prioritize Google Business Profile, and it may be one of your best lead generation sources. Ignore it and fail to update it regularly, and your competitors may be stealing many of your potential leads. 

You can directly influence the quantity and quality of leads you get from Google. How? By having consistent reviews, updated photos, and accurate service information.

Lead Generation Mistake #6: Lacking a Proven Follow-Up and Nurture Process

Today, people have options. They have multiple priorities. They’re easily distracted. Therefore, just because a prospect expresses interest in your home services solutions doesn’t mean they will become a customer.

Now more than ever, follow-up is critical for conversion. Only 2% of sales close on the first contact. 80% of successful sales happen between the 5th and 12th touchpoint.

If you don’t have a proven follow-up system tied to your home services lead generation system, you will lose out on far too many sales. Instead of trying to create another source of leads, pay more attention to the ones that come in.

Spartan Digital Fixes Your Broken Lead Generation System

The jobs you book, the revenue you make, and the profits you lock in each month are directly tied to the leads in your pipeline. Spartan Digital Solutions has a comprehensive approach to building effective lead generation systems for home services businesses.

How can we be so confident? Because our lead generation systems includes all of the components that drive qualified leads directly to you, including:

• A high-converting website
• Local SEO
• Google Business Profile optimization
• Paid advertising that converts
• Review generation
• Lead tracking
• Conversion optimization
• Follow-up automation

Now that’s an effective lead generation system. Because when all of these pieces work together, local service company marketing and sales become far more predictable and scalable.

Forget these lead generation mistakes, and march closer to a lead generation system that drives new business. Request your FREE Lead Generation Battle Plan, and discover why partnering with Spartan Digital can impact your bottom line. Through this Lead Gen Battle Plan, we will review your website, SEO, Google and AI visibility, paid ads, reviews, and conversion path. Then, you’ll know what’s holding your local service company back from generating more qualified opportunities.

Get Started

Ready to speak with a marketing expert?